Experience Eleuthera!

Where the edge of the Bahamas begins your escape from it all

Private Pink-Sand Beach

Enjoy exclusive golf cart access to our own private beach. Stroll three miles of pink-sands without a single house in sight.

Private Pink-Sand Beach

Caribbean Cove

Bask in calm turquoise waters a short walk down the hill. Grab a complimentary kayak, paddle board, or mountain bike from our sporting goods selection.

Caribbean Cove

Buttonwood Reserve Eleuthera's New Pickleball Court

Enjoy the fun of the world’s fastest growing sport on our private pickleball court.

Our New Pickleball Court

Heated Pool

Simply stay put under the shade of coconut palms, sunbathe on lounge chairs and swim at your leisure without leaving the yard.

Heated Pool

Accommodation

Where Comfort Meets Your Perfect Escape

Independently owned and operated Buttonwood Reserve of Eleuthera Island provides all the comforts of private island living at a neighborly rate.

Panoramic Ocean Views

Buttonwood Reserve offers the rare distinction of both Caribbean and Atlantic Ocean views from every unit. The sunsets are spectacular.

From $285/Night

Know More
Panoramic Ocean Views Rooms
Panoramic Ocean Views

Two Bedrooms, Two Baths

Sleeps 6! Relax with the help of a king bed, two twins that can convert to a king, as well as a sofa bed and a couch. En-suite baths are attached to each bedroom.

From $285/Night

Know More
Two Bedrooms, Two Baths Rooms
Two Bedrooms, Two Baths Condos

Stylish Full Kitchen

Get away from it all without going without. Every unit comes fully equipped & ready to host the whole family.

From $285/Night

Know More
Stylish Full Kitchen Condos
Stylish Full Kitchen Room

Balcony & Patio Seating

Take it all in with the help of tables & chairs on both sides of each unit. Star gazing at the edge of the Carribbean is hard to beat.

From $285/Night

Know More
Balcony & Patio Seating Area
Balcony & Patio Seating 5
Panoramic Ocean Views

Panoramic Ocean Views

Buttonwood Reserve offers the rare distinction of both Caribbean and Atlantic Ocean views from every unit. The sunsets are spectacular.

From $285/Night

Know More
Panoramic Ocean Views Rooms
Panoramic Ocean Views
Two Bedrooms, Two Baths

Two Bedrooms, Two Baths

Sleeps 6! Relax with the help of a king bed, two twins that can convert to a king, as well as a sofa bed and a couch. En-suite baths are attached to each bedroom.

From $285/Night

Know More
Two Bedrooms, Two Baths Rooms
Two Bedrooms, Two Baths Condos
Stylish Full Kitchen

Stylish Full Kitchen

Get away from it all without going without. Every unit comes fully equipped & ready to host the whole family.

From $285/Night

Know More
Stylish Full Kitchen Condos
Stylish Full Kitchen Room
Balcony & Patio Seating

Balcony & Patio Seating

Take it all in with the help of tables & chairs on both sides of each unit. Star gazing at the edge of the Carribbean is hard to beat.

From $285/Night

Know More
Balcony & Patio Seating Area
Balcony & Patio Seating 5

Activities

Explore Eleuthera Island

Eleuthera is a quiet, safe and friendly place to play outside. Buttonwood Reserve is an ideal home base for enjoying the entire island. Golf carts, kayaks, paddleboards & bikes are all free to help you along.

Cuisine With Culture

Dine at a pace and flavor you can only find on Island Time. Enjoy unique Carribbean, Upscale & Casual restaurants a short drive away.

Cuisine with Culture

Adventure Awaits At Buttonwood Reserve Eleuthera

Submerge yourself in colorful snorkeling. Cliff jump into deep blue springs. Ask us about charter fishing and other private excursions.

Adventure Awaits

Exotic & Inviting

Cozy private beaches are just the beginning. You can walk historical sights or even jump off a cliff on this unusual vacation destination.

Exotic & Inviting

Undiscovered Paradise

Eleuthera hides treasures at every turn. This wild slice of paradise has over 100 deserted beaches and inshore eco tours to explore.

Undiscovered Paradise

Amenities At Buttonwood Reserve

Amenities

Experience world class amenities

Indulge in thoughtfully curated amenities designed for effortless comfort and elevated living.

At Home

  • Free, fast Starlink Wi-Fi
  • Washer/dryer in each unit
  • Designer kitchen, fully equipped
View all

For the Beach

  • Golf carts for use on the property
  • Kayaks
  • Paddle boards
View all

On the Property

  • Heated pool
  • Lounge chairs
  • Pickleball court
View all

EVENTS

Weddings & Large Groups

Buttonwood Reserve offers multi-unit accommodations to comfortably host weddings, family reunions, and other events. Plan your next gathering with us.

Know More

Nearby

Discover the Best Of Paradise, Just Moments Away

  • Two oceanfront restaurants are a short walk from the resort.
  • Three grocery stores, a liquor store, and two restaurants can be found less than a mile away in the tiny village of James Cistern.
  • Head into the city of Governor’s Harbour for more stores, banks, bakeries, and restaurants including upscale options such as well-known Tippy’s, Buccaneer Club, and the Marriott’s elegant 1648.
Know More
Discover The Paradise

Testimonials

Hear What our Past Guest Have to say

Ranked #1 on Eleuthera

4.8
Star Ratings
1,000 + reviews on TripAdvisor. Certificate of excellence